建议,建议采纳,人工智能,人工智能建议 ," /> 建议,建议采纳,人工智能,人工智能建议 ,"/> advice taking, artificial intelligence, artificial intelligence’s advice ,"/> <div style="text-align:justify;"> Preference for Human versus Artificial Intelligence Advice: A Cognitive Mechanism Model of How Advice Source Affects Advice Taking </div>

Psychology: Techniques and Application ›› 2026, Vol. 14 ›› Issue (10): 629-640.

Previous Articles    

Preference for Human versus Artificial Intelligence Advice: A Cognitive Mechanism Model of How Advice Source Affects Advice Taking

  

  1. School of Psychology, Qufu Normal University
  • Accepted:2026-06-10 Online:2026-09-24 Published:2026-09-24

Abstract:

Existing research on whether people prefer to adopt advice from humans or artificial intelligence (AI) has yielded conflicting findings: Some studies demonstrate people’s preference for human advice, manifesting algorithm aversion, while others show preference for AI advice, indicating algorithm appreciation. Integrating the dual-attitude model and dual-system theory, constructs a cognitive mechanism model, which propose that people hold relatively positive explicit attitudes yet negative implicit attitudes toward AI (vs. human advisors). In addition, intuitive decision-making processes activate negative implicit attitudes towards AI, leading to aversion towards AI advice. Conversely, rational decision-making processes suppress negative implicit attitudes towards AI and activate positive explicit attitudes, resulting in a preference for AI advice. This model systematically explains why and when people prefer AI or human advice, and can integrate contradictory findings from the perspectives of dual attitudes and distinct decision processes. Future research should investigate the dynamic changes in dual attitudes toward AI and focus on implicit attitudes toward AI, thereby better facilitating positive human-AI interactions.

Key words:

CLC Number: 

  • B849
[1] SONG Minghua, XU Zhongkai, LIU Shen.
Prosocial Risk-Taking Behavior and Cyberbullying Bystander Behavior among College Students: Roles of Positive Psychological Capital and Interpersonal Trust
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(9): 523-533.
[2] LI Mengxia, ZHANG Peilin.
The Activation Conditions of Allocentric Reference Frames in the SNARC Effect: Evidence from a Picture Position Judgment Task
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(9): 554-563.
[3] QIAO Yanyang, CHEN Shimin, LIU Yan, ZHANG Chunyu.
The Longitudinal Relationship between Integration Strategy and Perceived Stress: The Mediating Role of Coping Styles
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(9): 534-541.
[4] GE Mengjiao.
From Theoretical Crisis to the Reconstruction of Meaning: A Review of Theoretical Psychology: A Cognitive Science Perspective
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(8): 508-512.
[5] ZHANG Xuan, ZHANG Xiaowen.
Association of Latent Profiles of Problematic Social Media Use and Intentional Self-Regulation with School Connectedness among College Students
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(8): 462-472.
[6] AN Yeqing, QU Mengyu, OU Jiayi, SONG Xiaonan, QI Shisan.
Research Progress and Theoretical Development of the Impact of Parental Marital Conflict on Child Development
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(7): 407-424.
[7] FU Jialin, WANG Shengyue, MA Gang.
Experienced Regret, Self-Protection Motivation and Consumer Preference
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(6): 359-370.
[8] CHEN Yuxin, XU Xiaopeng, XU Yueming, XIE Zixuan, ZHAO Na.
The Impact of Economic Scarcity on Gender Discrimination: The Moderating Role of Life History Strategies
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(6): 345-358.
[9] CUI Jinsheng, WANG Yonger, ZHONG Jianan.
Busy for a Reason: The Mechanism Linking Perceived Busyness to Status Consumption
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(5): 296-304.
[10] JIANG Wenbin, JI Tingting.
The Relationship between Sense of Virtual Community and Turnover Intention among Online Ride-Hailing Drivers: The Chain Mediating Effect of Occupational Identity and Psychological Distress
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(5): 268-277.
[11] ZHOU Jiantao, WEN Yang, ZHU Guiyang.
The Association between Sleep Quality and Employee Creativity: The Mediating Effects of Work Vitality and Creative Self-Efficacy
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(5): 285-295.
[12] LIANG Yuan, SONG Xinyi.
Revision and Validity Test of Chinese Version of Precrastination Scale
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(5): 313-320.
[13] ZHANG Ke, SUN Yujing.
Relationship between Maternal Educational Anxiety and School Adaptation of Primary School New Students: Moderating Role of Autonomy
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(5): 278-284.
[14] BAI Xiaoli, JIANG Yongzhi.
The Mechanism of Stress Perception in the Relationship between Money Scarcity Mindset and Money Environment Compound Intertemporal Decision-making
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(4): 216-225.
[15] JIN Lin, LI Kairong, WU Hao, ZHANG Hao, WANG Mingbo.
An Intervention Study of Full Life-Cycle Horticultural Therapy on Meaning in Life and Psychological Suzhi among University Students
[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2026, 14(4): 239-246.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

  Shared   
  Discussed   
[1] XIN Ziqiang, ZHANG Hongchuan, SUN Ling, YU Yonghong, XIN Zhiyong. The Definition and Triarchic Structure of Financial Literacy[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(8): 450 -458 .
[2] SUN Ling, SONG Xiaoxing, ZHOU Zhanqiang, MENG Xiangyi, XIN Ziqiang. The Concept, Construct and Measurement of Financial Knowledge[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(8): 459 -464 .
[3] ZHANG Hongchuan, SU Song, LV Jieyu, ZHANG Mei, XIN Ziqiang. Financial Capacity Based on the Rational Decision-Making View: Concept, Construct and Measurement [J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(8): 465 -471 .
[4] ZHANG Jingjing, YU Zhenzhen, TIAN Hao. An Integrated Model of Emotion and Ration on Pro-environmental Behavior: The Role of Ecological Emotion Involvement[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(8): 484 -492 .
[5] YU Xide, LU Cheng, GAO Dingguo. The relationships among Feeling of the Passage of Time,  Time Perspective and Personality[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(8): 493 -502 .
[6] WEI Xiao, LAN Jijun. Analysis of the Present Situation and Trend of Psychology Researchin China in Recent 10 Years ——Take the Dissertation Distribution of the 14th-19th China Congress of Psychology as an Example[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(8): 503 -512 .
[7] LIU Yang, LIU Xiaomeng, LI Shuangyi, WAN Zaojun, YUAN Yuan. The Impact of Parental Leadership on Job Satisfaction: the Mediation Effect of Supervisor-subordinate Relationship[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(9): 513 -521 .
[8] CHEN Bizhong. Positive Self-presentation in Social Network Sites and Subjective Well-being:A Multi-mediation Model[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(9): 528 -536 .
[9] HU Jinhui, XIN Cong, CHEN Youzhen. Effects of Encoding Strategies and the Salience of Cues on Prospective Memory[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(9): 537 -542 .
[10] LIN Tong, WANG Juan. Research on Spoken Word Comprehension in Visual World Paradigm[J]. Psychology: Techniques and Application, 2018, 6(9): 570 -576 .